• Menu
  • Skip to left header navigation
  • Skip to right header navigation
  • Skip to primary navigation
  • Skip to secondary navigation
  • Skip to main content
  • Skip to primary sidebar
  • Skip to footer

Before Header

Contact Us (317) 692-9000

  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • LinkedIn

Directions

Kroger Gardis Regas, LLP

Educational Resources

  • Firm
    • About Us
    • History
    • KGR in Our Community
    • Meritas
    • TAGLaw®
  • Professionals
  • Practice Areas
  • Information
    • Blog
    • Lenders’ Handbook of Loan Enforcement
    • Doing Business in Indiana: A Reference Guide
    • Representing Buyers and Sellers in Acquisitions of Privately Held Companies
    • Receiverships & Class Actions
  • Legal Lessons
    • Courses
    • Login
    • Account
  • News
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Search
  • Firm
    • About Us
    • History
    • KGR in Our Community
    • Meritas
    • TAGLaw®
  • Professionals
  • Practice Areas
  • Information
    • Blog
    • Lenders’ Handbook of Loan Enforcement
    • Doing Business in Indiana: A Reference Guide
    • Representing Buyers and Sellers in Acquisitions of Privately Held Companies
    • Receiverships & Class Actions
  • Legal Lessons
    • Courses
    • Login
    • Account
  • News
  • Careers
  • Contact
  • Search
You are here: Home / Blog / This Too Shall Pass…But When? Employer Medical Inquiries as a Pandemic Wanes

This Too Shall Pass…But When? Employer Medical Inquiries as a Pandemic Wanes

July 8, 2021 //  by Joseph Pettygrove

Amidst all the uncertainty of the COVID-19 pandemic, U.S. employers and their counsel found some well-deserved relief in EEOC’s March 2020 workplace pandemic guidance, plus its “What You Should Know About COVID-19” Q&A. EEOC confirmed—at least at that time—that the virus was “bad enough” that employers could do some things they normally couldn’t, specifically take employee temperatures and ask employees about certain symptoms. EEOC later confirmed employers could mandate vaccinations (subject to certain conditions including religious and disability-based exceptions). 

It’s helpful to know what employers can do, but the question still remains: for how long can they do it? A careful read of EEOC’s guidance confirms that it’s temporary, as it describes employer abilities with easy-to-miss qualifiers like “during [a/the] pandemic…” With phrases like “new normal” being used in other contexts, some may have forgotten that employers’ abilities to (lawfully) delve into and regulate their workforce’s medical status will go away when the pandemic itself abates.

But how long will that be?

EEOC’s current guidance applies as long as the pandemic is “more severe” than seasonal flu or the 2009 H1N1 virus or it remains “widespread” in “the community” as assessed by public health authorities. Those aren’t exactly bright-line metrics. And they’re not in any statute or regulation. Again, close reading of EEOC’s guidance suggests these concepts are best understood as applying the traditional ADA concept of “direct threat” to a situation affecting many people simultaneously. Normally, employers face strict limits on asking employees about their medical condition or imposing medical conditions on employment unless the employer can prove the specific employee’s condition presents a serious enough risk in their specific workplace. But when an infectious disease gets “bad enough,” there just isn’t time for that. Individualized analysis gives way to group-based infection control tactics.

EEOC’s latest updates emphasize the need to assess safety threats on an individualized basis, and many metrics used for tracking the severity and spread of COVID-19 in various geographies suggest the disease is fading overall. That’s welcome news for public health, but also cause for employers to remain alert for ADA exposure. At some point, EEOC is likely to withdraw its “national dispensation,” permitting employee medical inquiries and/or restricting its view on vaccination requirements. Independently, pandemic metrics in particular locales may support individual employee claims that COVID-19 is no longer a big enough threat to justify certain company-wide mitigation practices. Employers would do well to periodically assess those practices in light of the fundamentally “expiring” nature of EEOC’s ADA guidance.

Joe Pettygrove is a partner at KGR, and he advises management on a wide variety of employment and business issues. This article was originally published in Best Lawyers All Rise newsletter. KGR is ranked in 12 specialties for the 2021 Edition of U.S. News – Best Lawyers® “Best Law Firms.”

Category: Blog, Employment LawTag: Joseph Pettygrove

Previous Post: « Keep This in Mind: Considerations When Implementing COVID-19 Policy
Next Post: 4 Reasons to Create a Will (and Soon) »

Primary Sidebar

If you are interested in our services please fill out the form below.

RECENT POSTS

Indiana Leadership Foundation from the perspective of a KGR Associate

Leadership, Service, and Perspective

Reflections on My Indiana Leadership Forum Experience Last …

Women in Sports

Women in Sports: Ensuring Opportunity, Fairness and Safety

U.S. Senate Judiciary Committee Hearing September 23, …

A Human-Focused Approach to Professional Growth

Count the People in Your Day Think back over yesterday, but …

KGR Celebrates Attorneys Named to 2027 Best Lawyers in America List

The KGR family is incredibly proud of our attorneys recognized …

Governor Braun Appoints Ted Nolting to Marion County Judicial Selection Committee

Kroger, Gardis & Regas is proud to announce that Governor …

Footer

Indianapolis Office

Kroger, Gardis & Regas, LLP

111 Monument Circle, Suite 900 Indianapolis, IN 46204

(317) 692-9000
(317) 264-6832
Directions

Connect with us!

  • Facebook
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter

Copyright © 2026 · Kroger, Gardis & Regas, LLP · Log in